Understanding CARO 2020: A Practical Guide To Auditor Reporting Requirements

As of November 2026
Every statutory audit in India produces two documents that matter to readers outside the company. The first is the auditor's opinion on whether the financial statements give a true and fair view. The second is the Companies (Auditor's Report) Order, commonly called CARO, which sits as an annexure to that opinion and covers twenty-one clauses on how the company handled its assets, dues, borrowings, related parties, and governance during the year. CARO 2020 replaced CARO 2016 and applies to audits of financial years beginning on or after 1 April 2021. It added reporting points on undisclosed income, wilful default, fund diversion, whistle-blower complaints, cash losses, auditor resignation, material uncertainty, and CSR, and it expanded the clause count from sixteen to twenty-one. The practical consequence is that the auditor now certifies far more than the accounts. CARO reads like a structured health checklist, and companies that prepare for it before the auditor arrives spend far less time on follow-up queries.

Who CARO 2020 Applies To, and Who Is Exempt
CARO 2020 applies to every company, including a foreign company as defined under Section 2(42) of the Companies Act, 2013, unless the company falls within a specific exemption. The absolute exemptions are banking companies, insurance companies, companies licensed under Section 8, One Person Companies, and small companies. A private company that is not a subsidiary or holding company of a public company can also claim exemption if it satisfies three cumulative conditions: paid-up capital plus reserves and surplus not exceeding one crore rupees on the reporting date, total borrowings from banks or financial institutions not exceeding one crore rupees at any point during the year, and total revenue not exceeding ten crore rupees. The borrowing condition is tested across the whole year, not at the balance sheet date, so a company that drew down and repaid a large facility within the year may still fail the test even if the year-end figure looks comfortable.

The definition of a small company changed materially with effect from 1 December 2025. The paid-up share capital limit moved from four crore rupees to ten crore rupees, and the turnover limit moved from forty crore rupees to one hundred crore rupees. Because small companies are exempt from CARO, that single amendment took a large number of private companies out of the CARO net for FY 2025-26 and onwards. The small-company test uses the turnover of the immediately preceding financial year, taken from the profit and loss account. Because the amendment took effect in December 2025, commentary flagged ambiguity about the date at which small-company status is tested for FY 2024-25. Confirm the treatment against any MCA clarification before relying on the exemption for that year. Beyond the financial limits, the definition carries its own exclusions. A holding company, a subsidiary company, a Section 8 company, and a company governed by a special Act cannot be a small company regardless of their numbers. A private company that is a subsidiary of another private company can still use the private-company exemption route if it meets the one crore and ten crore tests, but it cannot rely on the small-company exemption. A public company can never be a small company. The applicability test should be documented at the planning stage of the audit and reassessed every year.

The Reporting Clauses: What the Auditor Actually Asks For
The twenty-one clauses in Paragraph 3 of CARO 2020 cover distinct areas. Grouping them helps companies prepare the right evidence in advance.

The asset clauses are 3(i) and 3(ii). Clause 3(i) covers property, plant and equipment, intangible assets, revaluation, and Benami properties. The auditor reports on whether proper records showing quantitative details and situation of assets are maintained, whether physical verification was conducted and material discrepancies found, whether title deeds of immovable properties are held in the company's name, and whether revaluation was carried out by a registered valuer. Clause 3(ii) covers inventory, physical verification, coverage and procedure, and discrepancies of ten per cent or more in aggregate for each class. It also requires a comparison of quarterly returns filed with banks against the books where working capital limits exceed five crore rupees.

The loan, investment, and statutory compliance clauses run from 3(iii) to 3(vii). Clause 3(iii) covers investments, guarantees, securities, and loans or advances, including whether any loan that fell due was renewed or settled through a fresh loan, and whether any loans are repayable on demand. Clause 3(iv) reports on compliance with Sections 185 and 186. Clause 3(v) covers acceptance of deposits and deemed deposits. Clause 3(vi) asks whether cost records specified by the Central Government under Section 148(1) are maintained. Clause 3(vii) covers statutory dues, requiring the auditor to report outstanding amounts as at the balance sheet date for more than six months from the date they became payable, and disputed amounts with the forum where the dispute is pending.

The remaining clauses run from 3(viii) to 3(xviii). Clause 3(viii) covers transactions not recorded in the books that were surrendered or disclosed as income in tax assessments. Clause 3(ix) covers default in repayment of loans or borrowings, whether the company is a wilful defaulter, whether term loans were applied for the purpose for which they were obtained, and whether short-term funds were used for long-term purposes. Clause 3(x) covers money raised by initial public offer, further public offer, preferential allotment or private placement of shares or convertible debentures, and whether the funds were applied for the stated purposes, along with compliance with Sections 42 and 62 for preferential allotments and private placements. Clause 3(xi) covers fraud by the company or on the company, and whistle-blower complaints, including whether the auditor has reported the matter to the Central Government under Section 143(12). Clause 3(xii) covers compliance by Nidhi companies with the Nidhi Rules, 2014. Clause 3(xiii) covers related party transactions and compliance with Sections 177 and 188. Clause 3(xiv) asks whether the company has an internal audit system commensurate with its size and nature, and whether the internal auditors' reports were considered by the statutory auditor. Clause 3(xv) covers non-cash transactions with directors. Clause 3(xvi) covers whether the company is required to be registered under Section 45-IA of the Reserve Bank of India Act, which is relevant to non-banking financial and core investment company activity. Clause 3(xvii) covers whether the company has incurred cash losses in the current and immediately preceding financial year. Clause 3(xviii) covers resignation of the statutory auditor during the year.

The final three clauses are 3(xix), 3(xx), and 3(xxi). Clause 3(xix) covers material uncertainty about the company's ability to meet its liabilities falling due within one year from the balance sheet date. Clause 3(xx) covers unspent CSR amounts and whether they were transferred to a fund specified under Schedule VII or to an unspent CSR account. Clause 3(xxi) is the only CARO clause that applies to the auditor's report on consolidated financial statements, and it asks whether the auditors' CARO reports on group companies included in the consolidation contain qualifications or adverse remarks.

Where Companies Struggle in Practice
The most common friction points are not the existence of the clauses but the quality of evidence behind them. Title deeds are a recurring problem, particularly for land held since before incorporation, for assets acquired through amalgamation where mutation is incomplete, and for leased assets recognised as right-of-use assets where the lease deed is in a promoter's name. Inventory discrepancies require a documented count, a reconciliation, and a clear conclusion, not merely a statement that a count took place. Statutory dues reporting requires ageing from the date the liability became payable, which is not always the invoice date, and disputed dues require the forum and the period to be stated precisely.

The fraud clause creates a different kind of pressure. The auditor must report whether any fraud by the company or on the company has been noticed, and whether the matter has been reported to the Central Government. The one crore rupee threshold for reporting to the Central Government comes from Rule 13 of the Companies (Audit and Auditors) Rules, 2014. The auditor reports the matter to the Board or Audit Committee within two days, seeks a response within forty five days, and forwards the matter to the Central Government within fifteen days of receiving the response, filing Form ADT-4. A company that has a whistle-blower complaint but no documented investigation will struggle to support a clean negative statement on this clause.

A Practical Way to Prepare
The companies that move through CARO smoothly treat it as a year-round discipline rather than a March exercise. Fixed asset registers are reconciled to the financial statements quarterly, title deeds are tracked in a register with mutation status, and inventory counts are documented with coverage and discrepancy notes. Statutory dues are aged from the due date, disputed demands are maintained with the forum and the period, related party transactions are mapped to Section 188 approvals before execution, and internal audit observations are closed with a documented management response. We at CA Dhiraj Ostwal & Co. have seen how much of the audit timeline is consumed by these items when they are left to the final week, and how little when they are maintained as part of the monthly close.

The Bottom Line
CARO 2020 applies to most companies but exempts banking, insurance, Section 8 companies, One Person Companies, small companies, and qualifying private companies within the one crore capital and borrowing and ten crore revenue thresholds. The small company limits were raised from 1 December 2025 to ten crore rupees of paid-up capital and one hundred crore rupees of turnover, but holding companies, subsidiaries, Section 8 companies, and companies governed by a special Act cannot use that exemption regardless of their numbers. The twenty-one clauses cover fixed assets and title deeds, inventory and working capital returns, loans and investments, Sections 185 and 186, deposits, cost records, statutory dues, undisclosed income, default and wilful default and end use of funds, fund raising and its utilisation, fraud and whistle-blower complaints, Nidhi compliance, related parties, internal audit, non-cash transactions with directors, RBI Act registration, cash losses, auditor resignation, material uncertainty, unspent CSR, and consolidated statements. The auditor's job is to ask the question and record the answer accurately. The company's job is to have the evidence ready before the question is asked.

Pranav ShelarShubham PadghanRuchika Borole

Connect With Trusted Chartered Accountant in India

Leave this empty:

Message us